Success StoryNDVI Can Be Wrong



NDVI Can Be Wrong

Author: John Grove

Planning Unit: Plant and Soil Sciences

Major Program: Grains

Outcome: Initial Outcome

In 2022 I gave a presentation where I showed that sensor Normalized Difference Vegetative Index (NDVI) values could result in an erroneous diagnosis of the causal nutrient deficiency. In early September of 2023 I was contacted by Darrin Malone, certified crop advisor/marketing specialist with AMVAC Corp. Mr. Malone had received a photo of one of my slides and was interested in a succinct explanation of the point. When I explained that the NDVI sensor sensed canopy color and extent, but could not distinguish amongst any nutrient deficiency (nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur) that could cause either color or extent to be insufficient without ground-truthing, he immediately understood the agronomy behind my position. He no longer recommends NDVI sensing for nutrient deficiency diagnosis/fertilizer recommendation without independent corroboration by plant tissue analysis.






Stories by John Grove


Helping a Novice Blueberry Producer

about 3 years ago by John Grove

I received a call from a beginning blueberry producer. Her plants, still in the pots and intended fo... Read More


Improving Plant Production Through Detailed Sampling and Diagnoses

about 3 years ago by John Grove

With Dr. Edwin Ritchey, Plant and Soil Sciences Soil Science Extension Specialist, and Greg Comer, O... Read More


Stories by Plant and Soil Sciences


Forage group completes national publication on 'Grazing Alfalfa'

Forage group completes national publication on 'Grazing Alfalfa'

about 3 years ago by Jimmy Henning

Grazing AlfalfaRay Smith, Krista Lea, and Jimmy HenningThe UK Forage Group has recently completed a ... Read More


UK Forage Group Establishes Teaching Pastures at Locust Trace AgriScience Center

UK Forage Group Establishes Teaching Pastures at Locust Trace AgriScience Center

about 3 years ago by Jimmy Henning

UK Forage Group Establishes Teaching Pastures at Locust Trace AgriScience CenterSpecialists and Staf... Read More